Friday, July 18, 2014

Critique: Women's Rights in Texas


Phillips provides a very interesting and well thought out opinion piece on Texas’ current political culture surrounding women’s issues. In her introduction, Phillips reminds the reader that Texas has been a leader in supporting women’s leadership roles in Texas in the past but our current male-dominated GOP leadership unfortunately is not as supportive of women’s rights. Throughout her article, she explains how the debate over the Senate Bill 5 regarding abortions has evolved into a much broader discussion on women’s rights.

I believe that Phillips does a good job of presenting the current situation without allowing any bias to weaken her argument. She explains that the male-dominated GOP leadership “are using the political process to advance their anti-abortion agenda.” However, she explains that Democrats, too, would likely advance their ideas if they were the majority. I think this is an important point to make that brings attention to the problems that can be associated with a legislation made up too heavily of of one political party with strong opinions.

Throughout the opinion piece, Philips details a few recent events that show evidence of the hostility towards women. The major issue, that of Senate Bill 5, enacts certain requirements for women seeking abortions and includes restrictions for abortions clinics which ultimately are aimed to drive them out of business. Additionally, Perry vetoed an act earlier this month aimed at ending pay discrimination against women. Both of these events contribute to Phillips argument that Texas is dealing with a broad range of women’s issues.


Wendy Davis continues to be a voice for Texas women, which is proving to be a difficult situation considering the political climate described above. However, Philips believes that Davis’ filibuster of Senate Bill 5 has brought much needed attention to women’s issues and seems to think the debate is beginning to favor the democrats.  

No comments: